Mikero
Super Robot
Posts: 11986
|
|
« Reply #100 on: 31 October 2008, 01:11:48 » |
|
We've said it all over why we didn't like it. We even admitted to being overly harsh. That is probably the best we're going to give you. Especially me, since I think this is some #####ty prank.
If you're genuine and thus genuinely want to improve, try reading all the posts. Do your best not to get personally offended (I know it's hard), and revise the parts people said they didn't like. For instance, it's rather ridiculous to make story about characters as if they live in a game world unless that's the idea like #####ing Code Lyoko or something. Just because the inspiration comes from a game, doesn't mean you need to list characters' HP all the time and have stuff like them going into "levels". Levels are just what people outside the game call them, from the perpective of the characters those are just places like the real life places you visit, such as the doctor's office where they treat you syphilis.
And random ##### about them playing video games that has nothing to with anything is crap. Crap. Anything that has to with nothing (which I'm not-so-afraid to say is the whole thing in this case) shouldn't be in your story.
Write like these aren't fake people. Type in real paragraphs. Use quotation marks, grammar, spelling, punctuation, line breaks, and every other literary tool you skipped (which is all of them safe for capitalising some letters).
Seriously, your posts are better than this trite, and they're not even good. And I still don't believe you're legit.
|
|
|
Logged
|
|
|
|
|
Jaker
Metall
Posts: 88
|
|
« Reply #102 on: 31 October 2008, 01:15:26 » |
|
... Posted on: 31 October 2008, 01:14:53
say no more please
|
|
|
Logged
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Mikero
Super Robot
Posts: 11986
|
|
« Reply #111 on: 31 October 2008, 01:27:00 » |
|
Look. That's as nice as I'm going to get about it. I'm not in a good mood in the first place, and I'm really not convinced yet of your earnestness.
My best advice is to get a book, right now. From somewhere in the house. A fiction book. One you've read and really like. Look in it a bit, see how it's written. Then look at your story and see how it isn't written. From there, you can revise it.
The whole story or lack there of wouldn't be so bad if it was AT LEAST formatted like a real story. I could actually do it FOR you, and it wouldn't take that long either, but that wouldn't actually be helping at all since you'd not learn anything.
I'd care so much less that it's not original and that it has random parts that mean nothing (which is something you can do, but only once you know how to do something are you able to correctly break the rules. TRUST me on this.) and all the other stuff it at least looked the part.
If you are indeed serious, you just have a lot to learn. Which isn't a crime, just very annoying for someone to give an honest critique about without being harsh. You can't write anything without reading, so read lots more books of all types. ESPECIALLY ones on how to write.
|
|
|
Logged
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Captain Sanoguchi
Super Robot
Posts: 3211
|
|
« Reply #116 on: 31 October 2008, 01:38:24 » |
|
This post grew up, but got left behind too. Write a story that isn't a recycled piece of crap. Come up with something original. Something new and creative.
1) Start with an original concept. Like a fire breathing cowboy who fights angels, demons, murderous high school students, and his conceived children that he didn't even know about.
2) Give it a story. Like the cowboy just got done traveling across the globe and has finally settled down in a city where his bounty hunting services are needed, and unknown to him he's actually being used as an advocate for the divine. Oh yeah, and he had a got a lot of women pregnant and left them so they had kids who were all special in their own way 'cause of stuff, like one's a demigod homosexual while another is a wheelchair bound, paralyzed telepath. So like, the kids were all born into hard lives and they blamed their father whom they never knew and stuff, so they all want revenge or something. Eventually they all track him down to the city. It all gets mashed into a bunch of gun battles, explosions, and semi-cliche lines about living and the future and stuff. At least it's interesting. Also, don't use that, I've been trying to weave that into a good tale for a few years now.
3) Add depth. Give the story depth. Describe the character's appearances, but not all of their features at once, draw it out a bit. Give all the characters unique personalities. Trying thinking about how they would act in a regular situation. If you don't make the characters have some sense of life or they'll all just be cardboard cutouts. Never write things like 'They fight!' or 'He walked.' Make everything sound interesting.
Yeah, do stuff better.
|
|
|
Logged
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Mikero
Super Robot
Posts: 11986
|
|
« Reply #124 on: 31 October 2008, 01:45:20 » |
|
Sano's story sounds a lot like Heroes! (Not really.) Anyway this thread is way too hot right now to ever post anything at a good time. Can u guys at least see if the 2ND one is any better?? if you want to send me a message telling me.
Did you upload it? No one is going to e-mail you to get it. Posted on: 30 October 2008, 20:44:24
if you have NOTHING nice to say say NOTHING at all!
Then you'll never improve or have a good story. Sorry, but that's... oh um... what's it called? Oh! Right! That's LIFE. Deal with it.
|
|
|
Logged
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Johncarllos
Super Robot
Posts: 6811
|
|
« Reply #132 on: 31 October 2008, 02:29:45 » |
|
Write a story that isn't a recycled piece of crap. Come up with something original. Something new and creative.
1) Start with an original concept. Like a fire breathing cowboy who fights angels, demons, murderous high school students, and his conceived children that he didn't even know about.
2) Give it a story. Like the cowboy just got done traveling across the globe and has finally settled down in a city where his bounty hunting services are needed, and unknown to him he's actually being used as an advocate for the divine. Oh yeah, and he had a got a lot of women pregnant and left them so they had kids who were all special in their own way 'cause of stuff, like one's a demigod homosexual while another is a wheelchair bound, paralyzed telepath. So like, the kids were all born into hard lives and they blamed their father whom they never knew and stuff, so they all want revenge or something. Eventually they all track him down to the city. It all gets mashed into a bunch of gun battles, explosions, and semi-cliche lines about living and the future and stuff. At least it's interesting. Also, don't use that, I've been trying to weave that into a good tale for a few years now.
3) Add depth. Give the story depth. Describe the character's appearances, but not all of their features at once, draw it out a bit. Give all the characters unique personalities. Trying thinking about how they would act in a regular situation. If you don't make the characters have some sense of life or they'll all just be cardboard cutouts. Never write things like 'They fight!' or 'He walked.' Make everything sound interesting.
Yeah, do stuff better.
That would make a swell comic book or TV show, but not much of a book. Maybe an illustrated book.
|
|
|
Logged
|
I can skin anything smaller than a bobcat in 30 seconds.
|
|
|
|
Captain Sanoguchi
Super Robot
Posts: 3211
|
|
« Reply #134 on: 31 October 2008, 02:55:50 » |
|
Write a story that isn't a recycled piece of crap. Come up with something original. Something new and creative.
1) Start with an original concept. Like a fire breathing cowboy who fights angels, demons, murderous high school students, and his conceived children that he didn't even know about.
2) Give it a story. Like the cowboy just got done traveling across the globe and has finally settled down in a city where his bounty hunting services are needed, and unknown to him he's actually being used as an advocate for the divine. Oh yeah, and he had a got a lot of women pregnant and left them so they had kids who were all special in their own way 'cause of stuff, like one's a demigod homosexual while another is a wheelchair bound, paralyzed telepath. So like, the kids were all born into hard lives and they blamed their father whom they never knew and stuff, so they all want revenge or something. Eventually they all track him down to the city. It all gets mashed into a bunch of gun battles, explosions, and semi-cliche lines about living and the future and stuff. At least it's interesting. Also, don't use that, I've been trying to weave that into a good tale for a few years now.
3) Add depth. Give the story depth. Describe the character's appearances, but not all of their features at once, draw it out a bit. Give all the characters unique personalities. Trying thinking about how they would act in a regular situation. If you don't make the characters have some sense of life or they'll all just be cardboard cutouts. Never write things like 'They fight!' or 'He walked.' Make everything sound interesting.
Yeah, do stuff better.
That would make a swell comic book or TV show, but not much of a book. Maybe an illustrated book.
Yeah, I know. I've come to that conclusion plenty of times already. Sadly, I don't know anyone who'd illustrate it for me, and I sure as hell don't know how to go about producing a television series.
|
|
|
Logged
|
|
|
|
|
|
Yubi Shines
Robot Master
Posts: 505
|
|
« Reply #137 on: 31 October 2008, 08:21:56 » |
|
Kiddo, if you're fixing to be a writer, you have to send your story to the publisher. (Or get an agent that'll do that for you. Either way.) Ain't no one's going to be asking YOU to send your manuscript to THEM. Who the heck are you? In the publisher's eyes, absolutely nothing.
And when you send the story out, the rejection slips will come. Granted, the people that'll review your story will be as subjective as anyone else, but they didn't get their job for no reason. If the rejection slips come with advice, consider it.
Then you keep sending the story, or you edit out the suck and then send it. Crippling depression and realizing you're a hack who can't write for crap is allowed, but then you get up and keep working at it.
Practically any artistic field is about 5% glorious inspiration from the gods, and 95% dogged hard work and thick skin. We live for the 5% because we're idiots. But there you go.
|
|
|
Logged
|
Vi Veri Veniversum Vivus Vici "By the power of truth, I, while living, have conquered the universe."
|
|
|
|
|
|
ChaosVortex
Super Robot
Posts: 5638
|
|
« Reply #141 on: 1 November 2008, 03:00:39 » |
|
|
|
|
Logged
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|